Don't understand the negativity from the press regarding United this morning

Before I knew the teams, I predicted a 4-0 win for City. After I saw the teams, I thought City might score 8. 

They were simply schooled by an excellent City side in the Second half. Bernardo Silva is still the best player City have.

The game was a reflection of where the teams currently are, nothing more than that.

Though I will say, I did not envisage that Ten Hag-ball would include spunking £120m on a GK and CF so we can play like Wimbledon in the 80s and 90s. United are not fun to watch at the minute.

Assume they are heading in the direction of Piccadilly.

They focus is because the gLOLazers have sanctioned more money spent on transfer fees and wages than any other club in world football in the last decade and it is still the same old shitshow. It’s quite incredible really.

Plus it generates clicks from tourist ‘fans’ like Davos.

I know a lot of football fans like 'net spend' (as we know experts like me don't look at it) 

But interestingly citeh's net spend is nearly 3bn more than United's (plus another billion put though citeh football group e.g. the day to salaries of admin staff etc)

Quite remarkable 

And yet United remain the only proper club, with everyone obsessing over us 

I know a lot of football fans like 'net spend' (as we know experts like me don't look at it) 

But interestingly citeh's net spend is nearly 3bn more than United's (plus another billion put though citeh football group e.g. the day to salaries of admin staff etc)

5 year net-spend table: https://www.football365.com/news/transfers-premier-league-five-year-net…

1) Chelsea: £-673.62m
23/24: £-168.66m
22/23: £-464.7m (12th)
21/22: £26.45m (3rd)
20/21: £-162.45m (4th)
19/20: £95.96m (4th)

 

2) Manchester United: £-608.9m
23/24: £-129.5m
22/23: £-196.62m (3rd)
21/22: £-94.8m (6th)
20/21: £-54.96m (2nd)
19/20: £-133.02m  (3rd)

 

3) Arsenal: £-552.76m
23/24: £-145.2m
22/23: £-144.08m (2nd)
21/22: £-116.25m (5th)
20/21: £-57.14m (8th)
19/20: £-91.59m (8th)

 

4) Tottenham: £-436.19m
23/24£-62.09m £-116.4m
22/23: £-118.93m (8th)
21/22: £-52.38m (4th)
20/21: £-83.08m (7th)
19/20: £-73.5m (6th)

 

5) Newcastle: £-416.08m
23/24: £-92.93m
22/23: £-147.05m (4th)
21/22: £-111.15m (11th)
20/21: £-33.1m (12th)
19/20: £-31.85m (13th)

 

Maybe fairer to have a 10-year net spend period.  Spend per trophy just for the lolz:

1. Manchester United

Transfer expenditure: €1.79billion
Transfer income: €465.74million
Net spend: €1326.42milion

Trophies won: 4
Net spend per trophy: €331.6million

2. Arsenal

Transfer expenditure: €1.38billion
Transfer income: €386.05million
Net spend: €995.72million

Trophies won: 4
Net spend per trophy: €248.93million

3. Chelsea

Transfer expenditure: €2.37billion
Transfer income: €1.38billion
Net spend: €992.41million

Trophies won: 8
Net spend per trophy: €124.05million

4. Liverpool

Transfer expenditure: €1.22billion
Transfer income: €769.67million
Net spend: €451.86million

Trophies won: 6
Net spend per trophy: €75.31million

5. Manchester City

Transfer expenditure: €1.79billion
Transfer income: €724.30million
Net spend: €1065.52million

Trophies won: 15
Net spend per trophy: €71.03million

6. Tottenham 

Transfer expenditure: €1.17billion
Transfer income: €694.02million
Net spend: €480.91million

Trophies won: 0
Net spend per trophy: N/A

The key difference between United and City is that they've both spunked about the same on players, but City have got more back, and that's because United have turned into a club which turns great or good players into mediocre players.  And City have made an art form of flogging reserve team players for decent cash (see Cole Palmer and James Trafford).

Correct, Pinko, save for in general it’s the incredible academy which generates that revenue.

Trafford was never a member of the first team squad. ditto Doyle, borges, bazunu, lavia, Sancho etc.

the academy gives a pathway for local working class lads who are truly elite (Foden/Lewis and tbf Palmer if he’d been patient).

For the rest, it’s a pathway into a very good career in pro ball.

For the club it’s a win/win.

My lad has joined an Academy.  He was never approached by City but we went to a United (satellite) one and it was a shambles.  Just another example of how United concentrate on the first team only and short-term results versus building something for the future.

Quite funny how me, a self respecting football finance expert and united fan, can lay a little crumb and bring all the Esher based tourist fans to bite 

Really guys, you need to learn the sport you say you care about 

What I have said is of course entirely correct, as ever