Could HR departments be replaced?

The consensus seems to be that they are expensive, full of thickies and have no obvious purpose. 

Oh dear.

Looks like poor little hyoobert has been hauled in for one of his regular chats about complaints received about him as a result of ‘the latest incident’

There are some hilarious examples of (generally) US companies who have done this, with predictable outcomes.

While I am certainly not defending all HR teams, and accept many HR professionals can be mediocre (UNLIKE LAWYERS EH FOLKS - THEY'RE ALL FVCKING BRILLIANT), most employees don't know what good HR people are actually doing, because (shock) it's often confidential.  

 

no, you need a human to investigate complaints, manage redundancy programmes and other dull but important jobs. pensions. LTIPs , compromise agts etc.

 

what do you think HG?

HR are some of my favourite people because they know all the best gossip and are completely fine with sharing if they trust you. How good they are is immaterial to me, as long as people get paid and they deal with wronguns when required. 

They’re  “employment lawyers” with no legal training 

They’re “human beings” with no humanity 

They’re “business partners” with no business skills 

 

I always thought it's quite a weird thing to 'want' to get into because no one wants to talk to you about anything and you generally have to behave like a bit of a creep.

Anyone would grew up thinking 'i want to work in HR' I am a bit suspicious of.

Tbf I wouldn't be able to do my job running a law firm if I had to deal with paperwork for on boarding, off boarding, water boarding etc 

So they are incredibly useful in law firms 

I appreciate HG has never been near running a law firm in his life 

Bright graduates come in thinking they will make the workplace, world etc.a better place - they don’t. 
Spend their time working on new or changing useless policies, training, workshops etc. that most lawyers despise, although the admin staff often like, as it is effectively time off. 
The worst seem to be those who have started off on the admin side and risen to what they consider to be great power, with no understanding of what drives professionals, we don’t care about their titles and we see through their tactics. 
Many of them are the worst kind of untrustworthy - falsely nice. 
With the rafts of ever changing rules and protections relating to a workforce, HR are sadly a necessary evil.

There is a basic flaw in HR departments which flaws them ab initio: they are often entirely staffed by women.  Not the demographic heterogeneity you expect from people responsible for implementing … a diversity policy.

A lot of their activity is the useful work of the dung beetle processing necessary admin in the dark. Unfortunately when it comes to anything more complicated they are usually overwhelmed